Bathroom Mirrors for Double Vanities

Okay, so I’ve been deep in bathroom planning mode for our upstairs remodel—specifically the mirror situation over our double vanity. And let me just say… I did not expect to have this many thoughts about mirrors.

But here we are.

There are way too many options, and naturally, I want something that looks amazing, fits the space just right, and doesn’t cost the same as a small appliance. While I was scrolling Wayfair with 42 tabs open, I figured I’d jot down the things I’m actually thinking about while trying to choose the right ones. Here’s what I’m keeping in mind -Hope it helps you feel a little more confident (or at least less alone in the decision spiral 😅).

1. Size Matters—A Lot

For a double vanity, your mirrors should be proportionate to the vanity itself. You can go two ways:

• Two separate mirrors (one over each sink) for a more symmetrical, custom feel.
• One long mirror that spans the entire vanity for a cleaner, more modern look.

Rule of thumb: Aim for mirrors that are about 70-80% the width of your vanity.

2. Mind the Height

Your mirror shouldn’t just look good—it should also reflect your actual face. (Shocking, I know.) A general rule is to hang the mirror so the center sits at eye level, which is typically around 60 inches from the floor. If you and your partner have a noticeable height difference—split the difference or opt for taller mirrors.

Seems obvious, but you’d be surprised how often people wing it here. Make sure you’re accounting for:

• The backsplash height
• The faucet height
• The vanity countertop thickness
• The light fixture drop

Ideally, the mirror should start a few inches above the faucet and stop a few inches below your lighting fixture for a balanced look.

3. Shape + Style Should Match the Vibe

Your bathroom mirror is like the earrings to your outfit—it ties the whole look together.

• Arched or rounded mirrors = soft, feminine, trending.
• Clean-lined rectangles = timeless and minimal.
• Wood or metal frames = great for layering texture or matching other finishes.

Stuck on what style to go with? Pull cues from your faucet, cabinet hardware, and lighting. Matchy-matchy isn’t required, but harmony is your friend.

4. Think About Function (Not Just Aesthetics)

Do you need storage? A built-in medicine cabinet might be more useful than you think. Need task lighting? Then a frameless mirror with wall sconces might be the move.

Also, think about how easy it’ll be to clean. Those intricate frames with grooves and crevices? Gorgeous. But also dust and grime magnets.

5. Lighting, Lighting, Lighting

This isn’t just about the mirror—it’s about what’s around it. Your lighting setup can totally change how the mirror looks and how you look in the mirror. If your lights are above the mirror, consider the height and how the light will cast. If you’re doing sconces on the sides, make sure your mirrors leave enough room.

Don’t forget: Always measure your wall space twice before ordering sconces and mirrors. The combo can get cramped fast.

Alright, now that I’ve overanalyzed every possible mirror angle, style, and size, I wanted to share some of my favorite finds from Wayfair that made the short list for our double vanity. These are all budget-friendly, stylish, and actually practical. I could make 10 more of these posts will all of the great mirrors I’ve come across and I promise to share them all so you don’t have to do the digging! But, for now, let’s start with this one…

1. Ancalin Wood Accent Wall Mirror for Bathroom Bedroom Decorative Mirror
2. Katerina Wood Arch Wall Mirror
3. Haslem Recessed Framed Medicine Cabinet with Mirror and Adjustable Shelves
4. W H Recessed Framed Medicine Cabinet with Mirror and 2 Adjustable Shelves
5. Ancell Solid Wood Rectangle Mirror
6. Sherman Wood Rectangle Mirror
7. Morelock Metal Rectangle Mirror

This post contains affiliate links. If you click through and make a purchase, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you.